HomeschoolForms.com Archives

HSF: Discussions between Homeschoolers

What is the Best Curriculum?

Posted

Advertisements
cm_dean
My name is Christie, I am from Georgia. I have two daughters. One is 12 and the other is 14. This is my first time homeschooling. I have a few questions but the main one for now is what is the best curriculum? I have been looking at Abeka... then I found another one that I may be interested in... "Core Curriculum of America." Can anyone give me any info on those... What is your opinion on them? I like that the Core Curriculum gives you customized packages for each individual.
Help & Thanks! help2.gif
Again
I don't use either ... I just wanted to say Hi from another Georgian!! flower3.gif

We are following The Well Trained Mind ... and we love it. It is not a prepackaged thing ... you just find what works and plug it into their outline. I like the freedom.

There is someone here who has been using Abeka ... maybe she'll jump in and give you her experience. You'll find though that as you learn how your kids learn that your choices will change. Don't put all your stock in just one thing ... it may not be a good fit. Try something and if it doesn't work ... trust me, you'll change it. I have gone from being a total "unschooler" to classical education nut! You just never know what will work. ... and that is half the fun. whistling.gif rolleyes.gif
quiltinmommy
What a loaded question! The truth of it is there is no perfect curriculum, everyone has an opinion. Abeka is a good curriculum, my only hesitation with starting it with 12 and 14 year olds is that it's an advanced curriculum... it may be ahead of your girls. I found it difficult to jump into a curriculum like this...we tried Calvert, my daughter was not ready at the time.

I've heard of Core Curriculum of America but I don't know much about it.

I am very eclectic in my style ... we use a little bit of this and a little bit of that. If I was going for a box curriculum, I would look at Hewitt (I love their resources for older kids!!!), Bob Jones (also an advanced curriculum), Sycamore Tree or Sonlight. If you would like to mix and match, I can also point you to resources. My kids are similar in age, I have 8, 11 and 13 (grades 2,5,8).

Hewitt Homeschooling

Bob Jones University Press

Sonlight Curriculum

Sycamore Tree

Good luck!
HomeschoolLady03
I have used A Beka for 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and now 5th grades. We absolutely love it. yes.gif

It is advanced, as compared to what *our* local public schools are doing. (My sis is student teaching in 5th grade at our public school.)

It is a Christian curriculum. I do not go by the curriculum guides. I do all my own planning and so forth. (I may change that dunno.gif )

A Beka is either a "love it" or "hate it" sort of thing for most people. Some people love the structure, while others hate it.

I will say that I also use other things to supplement A Beka. I supplement in writing and reading.

Good luck in your decision. flower3.gif
jessicasmom
I have used Sycamore Tree for the past 2 years because if you buy their complete curriculum package you get the lesson plans which have helped me as a fairly new homeschooler.

Heather in Fl. smile.gif
krodriguez
Hello and welcome! We only use A Beka for math and we will not be using it next year. I think we will be going with Saxon next year for math, just not sure yet.

I have heard lots of good things about A Beka, but we have not been impressed. I, too, have heard it is advanced, but we used the same stuff our public schools used last year for math and we had no problems starting right up this year. (Well, no problems with the math part ... starting up, that was another thing! wreck.gif ) Of course, my girls are doing 2nd and 3rd grade math and that could have a lot to do with it.

I wish I could answer your other question, but I have not heard anything about it until now. Good luck! In the end, I am sure it will all work out! yes.gif
Nana
flower3.gif

My kids are younger than yours but I am using:

Saxon for Math

Zaner-Bloser for Spelling and handwriting,

CLE for Reading (for now)

Science is anything I find for it; as I have not found one I like yet..

Social Studies we are doing a unit type thing and studying the US state by State and making a notebook/scrapbook for them. My husband travels so he gets postcards from the states he visits and maps and other things.

Music is whatever we listen to a lot of classical

and

Art we do a lot of arts and craft type things at this time ...

I hope this helps, just wanted to let you know you do not have to like all of any curriculum... Use what best fits YOUR children.

Good Luck and Welcome.

Nana
flower3.gif

siscaboo1512
We are still learning. We don't use a curriculum per say. We are still looking for a good fit for us. Just keep looking and researching and experimenting until you find what is right for you.
mom-to-five
well I have to agree with whoever said that abeka seems to be a hate it or love it curriculum!!! We do not like it but , then again we are not go completely by the book kind of learners!!!

It may take some time before you figure out what works best... I know it did for us!! We us Saxon and Singapore for math ( different math for different kids), Apologia for science for everyone this year, all though we have used Sonlight for science before and liked it a lot as well. Let me see, Easy Grammar, Streams of Civilization for history, and Story of the World ( again, different stuff for different kids) I think that is what I like best about homeschooling is I can use what ever works for each of my kids.

I hope all goes well in your first year and welcome to our group!! flower3.gif
gsmp
I use Abeka with a mix of Bob Jones, Saxon Math and Spelling Power.

I like the Abeka program but it can be overwhelming. There is a lot of work to do and it is very repetitive. I supplement with Bob Jones reading because it forces them to think and reason out the story.

I have an 11 year old daughter who is in the 7th grade. She needed a reading that would make her question.

Overall curriculum choice is going to be what works for you. There are a lot of good programs out there but it depends on what you are expecting from yourself and your kids.

The first year is always the hardest ... so I've been told. blush.gif . We are going into our second year.

Ask away though ... this is definitely the place to be ...
cm_dean
See, I am so confused since this is the first time that I have ever done homeschooling and being as there are so many options I don't have a clue other than to order a complete curriculum. Even though what I have heard from the replies here. I had no clue that you could order from different places. This is really confusing. I read that " Core Curriculum of America" offers the lesson plans and many extras. Plus it's not near as costly as A Beka... Is it better to be hands on with your children or is it better to let them learn from a dvd?
Thanks so much for your help!

Christie wall4.gif
Again
I think whether you are hands on with your kids or not depends on your kids ... can you count on them doing the work assigned with minimal brow beating? yes.gif Or would they require you to be constantly looking over their shoulder and guiding them?user posted image

I think what most of us have done is to finally just pick something and run with it...you will know pretty quickly whether it is a good fit or not. And if it isn't ... you may not have to change the whole curriculum (expensive), but just some aspects of it. There is no law about changing things to suit your particular situation. You will not ruin your kids for ever! If nothing else you will be learning a lot together about so much more than history dates and scientific formulas. clap.gif

By the end of this year you will be a pro ... .I know you will! You love your kids more than any teacher, etc. and so you will do your best for them. Maybe let them see what a struggle it is to do this for you ... they may appreciate it more and help make some of the decisions ... if they seem ready for that.

Maybe you should figure out what your goals are for the kids this year. Write out the courses and the goals that you would like to accomplish ... that may be a good starting point.

Ask more questions here ... we have nothing to do all day! Oooops! I mean we are schooling and love to help ... whistling.gif Phew! almost gave away my Forum addiction! roflol.gif roflol.gif

gsmp
The ladies out here are so awesome you can't go wrong by the advice and suggestions.

You have to remember that it boils down to what you are also comfortable with doing.

I went with Abeka our first year because the kids were all ready used to it and I was familiar with it. They came from a Christian school to homeschooling.

When we went to our first Homeschool convention last year ... My husband was so overwhelmed ... he couldn't believe the options that are out there.

I chose to go with a curriculum that offered the lessons plans spelled out for me. I needed that to start out with and still do. It gives a guide to follow.

Another option is to get a copy of your states scope and sequence (what they require you to cover for those grades) . This will also be of some benefit and help you see which way you are going.

Some of the Christian Curriculums are ahead of the public school so you may want to find one that will do placement testing for you. I know that 90% of the curricula do offer these. A lot of times this is offered free if you choose a particular group or there is a small fee.

Don't drive yourself nuts trying to figure all this out in one short time. I have friends that have tried something and it not work for them ... they had the luxury of ordering a replacement curricula Others have just thrown away the lesson plans and made up their own thing as they went along.

You've gotten a lot of really good advice from the ladies here like Pam and quiltinmommy ... not meaning to leave anyone else out blush.gif . They're all great ideas ... Once you get started ... it won't seem so bad ... the choosing is the worst I think ... whistling.gif
mtbriere
This is my 2nd year of homeschooling and I'll be honest, we spent just as much time switching curriculums as actually studying last year. And my dc were 4th, 6th, and 8th grades last year. Just remember to give yourself time, and I agree that you are not going to mess them up. I'd have to say that even though our academic year wasn't the greatest, my dc matured TREMENDOUSLY!!

I have a great curriculum this year and the dc are loving school and doing well. We are very eclectic. I use Christian Liberty Academy Christian Liberty Academy for my oldest in high school because she wants the transcripts, etc. They are also very flexible.

Anyway, the ladies here have given you wonderful advice, but it boils down to what works best for you. And again, it takes time and trial to find this out.
lm4jc
Hello from yet another Georgian! I just joined this forum but I thought I'd post right away. The other posters are correct - there is no perfect curriculum. You will probably find that you will change your mind several time over the years before finding what really works for you. Some of what you need to decide is how your children learn best, and what goals in the format of your schooling you have. I'll give you some example:
--do you want your children to work primarily independently with little actual teaching from you?
--do you want to teach them together for some subjects?
--do you want to do projects and hands on activities as the primary learning method?
--do your children prefer workbooks or textbooks or unit studies or video ... ?
--do you want to have everything pre-planned or do you prefer to formulate your own lesson plans?
--will you use textbooks for literature and history or "living books"?

You get the idea. There are so many things to consider before choosing a curriculum. I homeschool all of our 8 children and so we strive for independence in a big way. I want my kids to understand that life will not spoon-feed them information and they will have to teach themselves what they want to learn. But I also have some struggling learners that require more specialized curriculum materials suited to low-ability readers. We don't do many hands-on projects or activities simply because it takes us most of the day to do the basic stuff.

Overall, I have found some materials that I like better than others.
--Climbing to Good English (A complete workbook style English for grades 1-8. Used in the Amish schools. Not colorful or fancy but very comprehensive. Lots of writing. You would need a separate spelling program. These workbooks are very inexpensive. If you choose these expect to be gin at a lower grade level than what your kids are in.)
--Apologia Sciences (www.highschoolscience.com)
--Teaching Textbooks Math (www.teachingtextbooks.com. Expensive but VERY worth it!)
--Wordly Wise (vocabulary workbooks)
--Landmark Freedom Baptist Curriculum (Can be used even if you are not Baptist, but definitely Christian-oriented. Can buy one subject or a complete grade package. These are self-directed workbook style courses with minimal teacher involvement.)
--Steck Vaugn products are great for low-level readers or struggling learners. (www.steck-vaughn.com)

Also, you should check out ww.unitedstreaming.com for online videos in all subjects. This is FREE for Georgia residents!! You can download the videos or watch them online. Plus many have teacher guides and worksheets available with them. This is a fantastic resource!

Author
Categories

Comments

Commenting is closed for this article.

← Older Newer →

RSS / Atom

External links

You may find articles similar to What is the Best Curriculum? in the categories:
   

Related Articles

15 Random Articles

Homeschooling

at DonnaYoung.org

handwriting paperapologia science lesson plans and resourcesblank-top papergrade cardscale paperbookletmonth on a page filler papermultiplication charts